Should You Remodel or Replace Cabinets? Pros and Cons

A guide from Ridgeback Builders to help Florida homeowners decide between cabinet refacing and full replacement.

By Ridgeback Builders
Should You Remodel or Replace Cabinets? Pros and Cons

Kitchen cabinets play a huge role in the look, storage, and functionality of your space. But when it comes to upgrading, many homeowners wonder: Should I replace or remodel my cabinets? The answer depends on your goals, budget, and the condition of your current cabinetry. If you're planning a kitchen renovation in Florida, here’s a detailed breakdown of the pros and cons of cabinet remodeling vs. full replacement.

Option 1: Remodeling (Refinishing, Refacing, or Painting)

Remodeling your cabinets involves keeping the existing cabinet boxes in place and updating the surface. This could mean sanding and painting, changing the doors (refacing), or installing new hardware.

  • Pros of Cabinet Remodeling
    • Cost-effective: Remodeling is significantly cheaper than replacing all cabinetry.
    • Quick upgrade: Most refacing or repainting projects take 2–5 days.
    • Minimal disruption: No need to tear out cabinets or change layouts.
    • Eco-friendly: Reusing cabinet boxes reduces waste.
    • New look on a budget: With updated doors, colors, and handles, you can completely transform the space.
  • Cons of Cabinet Remodeling
    • Structure must be solid: This only works if your existing cabinet boxes are in good condition.
    • Layout stays the same: Remodeling doesn’t allow you to change the kitchen’s function or flow.
    • Less long-term durability: Painted or refaced cabinets may not last as long as brand-new ones.
    Best For: Homeowners who want a fresh look without a full gut renovation—especially in budget-conscious kitchen makeovers.
Drying process

Replacing Cabinets Completely

Replacing cabinets means tearing out the old boxes and installing brand-new cabinetry from scratch—either custom-built or pre-fabricated.

  • Pros of Cabinet Replacement
    • Full design flexibility: Change your layout, add storage, or reconfigure workflow.
    • Modern features: Soft-close drawers, deep pullouts, hidden trash bins, and custom organizers.
    • Long-term durability: New cabinets typically come with warranties and are built to current standards.
    • Increased home value: A brand-new kitchen with modern cabinetry appeals to buyers and adds resale value.
  • Cons of Cabinet Replacement
    • Higher cost: New cabinets (especially custom) are one of the most expensive parts of a kitchen remodel.
    • More time-consuming: Full replacement can extend your renovation timeline.
    • May require new countertops or backsplash adjustments: Changes in dimensions can lead to additional upgrades.
    Best For: Homeowners planning a complete kitchen renovation in Florida who want to improve layout, storage, and functionality long-term.

Ready to Start?

We blend smart design with technical excellence to build projects that last and impress.

BOOK FREE CONSULTATION
← BACK TO ALL ARTICLES

Serving Lehigh Acres, Fort Myers, Naples, Port Charlotte, Sarasota, Tampa, Bradenton, West Palm Beach, Port St. Lucie, and nearby cities.

Should You Remodel or Replace Cabinets? Pros and Cons | Ridgeback Builders